This led to it having an anime-only ending, unlike Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood which would air years later. And then he leaves and we never see him again. Further, the characters had distinctive personalities. Log In Sign Up. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood tops three of these five lists and it's second and fourth on the other two, meaning it can be easily considered the highest rated and most critically acclaimed (by the viewers) anime series EVER. While FMA Brotherhood isn't my personal favorite anime ever, still earns a 10/10 on my list and I can definitely see why many people do consider it so and why it is consistently top-rated. 145k. In the anime, we only briefly hear about … I will see you there. Now in most anime, this should be the last we hear of Rose. 237. engaged in research. She forces her way into Rush Valley to become a highly valued mechanic, she comes up with the plan for Scar to take her hostage, she is the one who ultimately agrees to give her life to Edward using logic he had never thought of before. An anime fan can easily watch the show and absolutely love it, but so can somebody who isn't really into anime. User account menu. Created Nov 4, 2011. You can easily find posts of people detailing the parallels between the deaths of the homunculi and Dante's Divine Comedy. See more posts like this on Tumblr. When he's fighting Pride with the chimeras, he uses a Philosopher's Stone despite his earlier resistance because he recognizes it will save more lives and it's the purely rational thing to do. So, my question is: which aspects do you think make Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood the undoubtedly most prestigious anime series ever created? Recommendation. but now i’m feeling super empty, does anyone have good suggestions for a series … Press J to jump to the feed. That's what it means to be married. Feel free to share! Anyway, the storyline is another aspect that could have left FMA:B flat on its face, but instead serves as another strength. The heroes had high morals and never took a shortcut to their destination. animeatemyfeels liked this . Let me know, bye! Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood tops three of these five lists and it's second and fourth on the other two, meaning it can be easily considered the highest rated and most critically acclaimed (by the viewers) anime series EVER. He recognizes he has a disability, but he doesn't allow it to control him; Alphonse controls what should hinder him and turns it into a weakness. Come post anything related to Hiromu Arakawa's Fullmetal Alchemist anime and manga franchise! From now until April 8th, … Their independent actions and their interplay were phenomenal. alchemists and alkahestrists. No. For example, let's take a look at Rose (though not really a villain in this case), a fairly minor character whom our protagonists meet early in their adventure. However, imagine my surprise when 20-30some episodes later, the brothers return to the town and we meet Rose again, who is helping rebuild the town and feeding the hungry! Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood-Complete Series [Blu-ray] at Amazon.com. fullmetal alchemist ending reddit December 30th, 2020 by in UncategorizedUncategorized Vote. I recently finished fullmetal alchemist brothers and I loved it!! The references to Nazi Germany are not hard to follow, nor are many other aspects of the themes FMA portrays: togetherness, forgiveness, questioning your basic assumptions, recognizing the "other" is not so different from you. Some members of the cast are rogues, some are soldiers, and others are simply madmen or monsters. It doesn't come easily for him, either, but at his heart, he understands that the best way to honor his memory is not to seek vengeance, but continue his work. We know Edward and Alphonse are the main characters, and they rightly grow up before our eyes. It has something going on for all kind of fans and is pretty easy to digest. WARNING: What lies ahead is full of spoilers, my biased opinions, and as always, analysis that might just be BS in the end. How many established critics think of it as a masterpiece (and how do you even define what an established critic is)? But it is how I view FMA:B, which is apparently what you asked for, so here's your heads up. Characters have flaws, find a way to cope with them, and you can see the passage of time. Even after he helps save the world, his failure to save Nina keeps him grounded. This made it very accessible for a lot of casual anime fans. You can be any age, any gender, and have an interest in any genre, and you will still probably enjoy it. Too many series try to slip up characters to make way for a nuance, or even large element, to drive the plot the way they want it to go. Now which one of you will be the one to end the king's life? Questions, discussion, analysis, fan art, cosplay, quality memes, etc. What is the metric for entertainment quality? "/"Race, gender, origin, name, none of that matters now. Every character was genuine to themselves and their beliefs. Is it the best film ever made? RELATED: Food Wars Season 5 Differs From Th… She has a slender, girlish figure and is slightly taller than Edward for most of the story. Hello y'all, it's been a long time since I don't write a thread. Anonymous asked: can I ask what software you use to take the screenshots of every ep? Too many shows either drag on, are cut short, or have too many loose ends. Oh, and Lan Fan cut off her fucking arm to save her lord (and thereby any chance of saving her clan) and started using automail within six months after hearing puny Edward did it in a year. Her reappearance was by no means necessary, but the continuity here helps sell the world and the characters so much more. Of the two, though, I love Alphonse's path much more. 3ayyn liked this . I apologize for the giant wall of text. Further, the characters were not broken for plot or story convenience. Hiromu Arakawa's hit anime Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a fantasy action series packed with cool fight sequences, stunning set pieces, deep philosophy, and of course, all kinds of memorable and complex characters. I have it rated as 10/10 myself but I don't think its one of the strongest 10s I have. It's fuckin rad. Kotobukiya has announced the re-release of two statues from the hit anime Fullmetal Alchemist.Two fan favorites are back and kicking off the returns is the Fullmetal Alchemist … 03 has the better atmosphere and … Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is without a doubt one of the greatest shows to ever be written by a human being. There, Amestris is a landlocked nation surrounded by other countries, and sometimes border skirmishes occur. We all know about Maes's death and Nina the chimera, but don't forget Armstrong's inability to stop anything in the Ishval war despite having all this strength, Captain Buccaneer's heroic death (with two of my favorite lines of all time: "How about we walk King Bradley down to hell together? Option 4: Watch Full Metal Alchemist all the way through, then the movie. It's not the very best at any one thing, but basically everything it does, it does extremely well, and has such a wide range of appealing pieces that people drawn in by just one thing end up enjoying a solid whole. "/"Every choice in my life was made for me... except her. I could easily talk about a slew of things that made the show great such as compelling characters, an epic story, great themes, and excellent voice/animation. In FMA: B, we actually see the characters change. The future most powerful man in the country trusts one person with his back completely, and that person is Riza Motherfuckin Hawkeye. And everything that gets brought up in the beginning has its place at the end, like the aforementioned swap of Alphonse's soul for Edward's arm (also fucking Mei fully committed to sacrificing the life of the man she loves to save the world), the mentions of Ishval and the presence of the homunculi throughout time, the bits and pieces of Father, the set up of Selim as a homunculus (also that amazing scene of Riza and Roy talking in code), Maria Ross's fake burning and her return, Havoc being consigned to a wheelchair but still contributing in any way he can to the man he committed his life to, Bradley's hands shaking at Hughes's funeral only for it to be revealed as anger later, Hoenhein's counter circle, etc. Alright so it's getting late here and I'm on mobile because I'm on vacation but screw it this essay is gonna get written. In summary, part of what makes FMA: B great for me is the attention and care given to its characters. Which are FMAB's strongest points and why? It’s a remarkable work of fiction that … Winry is an attractive young woman with long, light blonde hair and blue eyes. This post created by the fabulous Kruzy includes a comparison of five different top 25 anime lists. It is implied that the bad guy becomes a better person but the rest is up to our imagination. FMA: B has a massive cast whose stories take place all over the country and it still amazes me that every single character feels fully fleshed out and realized. For more on this, just look up feminist Fullmetal Alchemist essays that serve as character profiles on those gals. This is purely from the viewpoint of FMA:B and a little bit of the manga (I haven't seen the 2003 version nor have I played any of the games, so I can't speak to those). everyroymustang posted this . For me, world building and character writing are tied for "most important" in a series. IMDb is not included in Kruzy's post but you can check it out here: FMAB is the second highest rated anime series only behind Hunter x Hunter (2011) and the fourth one if we count worldwide animated TV series. The dub's good, it's not too "Japan-y," and it stays pretty grounded in the rules that it sets early on. I tried to think about what made FMA: B unique and stand out from all the other anime I've seen. But for the sake of time, I'll stick to the one aspect which I enjoy above all else in anime: the characters. I finished the series about a month ago, having not seen the previous adaptation or read the manga. RELATED: Fullmetal Alchemist: 10 Most Terrifying Scenes, … If I had to single out the defining feature that made FMA: B great for me, it is probably that the show is simply really well-balanced. It's rare, at least in my experience, to find such well developed and well written women in shounen. Watch Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood episodes and follow Edward and Alphonse Elric as they seek the Philosopher's Stone to restore what they've lost. Same show Nanatsu no Taizai is an adventure/shounen anime series awesome shots and a unbelievable.... Weekly Recommendation Thread helpful r/fullmetalalchemist: … The story, the animation, the character development, the philosophical subtext, the political commentary, the sub-plots, the finale, the soundtrack, the humour, the antagonists, the supporting characters, the dramatic twists, etc. The reason FMA Brotherhood is always rated so high isn't because it's the best anime of all time, but because it has such a broad appeal. Ed and Al’s mother is struck down by illness for no good reason. Your characters are allowed to change, and this change can be rapid depending on the scenario, but you can't have a lapse of character. For a series whose genre dictates more of an emphasis on action and battles, the story takes care to pace its characters in such a way that it reveals aspects about them that you never could have imagined in the beginning, twists them, and then twists them again. A gentleman artist through and through, he considers his alchemically-induced explosions to be of the highest aesthetic and aims to make them as \"beautiful\" as possible in terms of scope, destructive capability and sound - sound apparently being the most important criterion based on his oft-showcased keen ear for explosives and his manic enthusiasm for loud eruptio… Especially remarkable is its unstoppable reign at the top of My Anime List, considering the site is the most popular anime-related website. Suddenly, we're not so much focused on trying to pick up everything that happens along the ride and instead can choose to enjoy and delve into whatever aspect piques our interest the next time around... and with all that went into this series, you can never be quite finished with details to discover. In the manga (and subsequently, the 2009 anime series based thereon), Kimblee is as much a philosopher as he is a psychopath. It's probably also that it's relatively accessible, even to a western audience. In my opinion? (Sidenote: How fucking metal is that? Having watched the show both sub and dub at least three times each (and the manga front to back too many times to count), I'm relying mostly on my memory for this, so please feel free to correct me if I slip up. alchemists and alkahestrists. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. There's a question that I'd like to discuss with you. 1 - Well-Developed Characters (especially women! I think story progression is the absolute key! Instead, I've found it only enhances the experience. The bad guy realizes the error in his ways and swears that he will change. Close. FMA is different from the norm for a variety of reasons: it's an action shounen written by a woman, there's little emphasis on fanservice, it is very much based in a "Western" world, from the names to the city structures, etc. Come post anything related to Hiromu Arakawa's Fullmetal Alchemist anime and manga franchise! That gives me a 1060p screenshot of the show without a watermark or anything in the corner. How many people thinks of it as their favorite? Brotherhood is as close to being like a good epic novel as anything on TV. Top posts december 4th 2015 Top posts of december, 2015 Top posts 2015. help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit … The perfect FullmetalAlchemist Anime Greed Animated GIF for your conversation. Many series suffer from assuming badass females = good female character writing. Well said. With 64 scenes, the Brotherhood is longer than the first, which is a 50-scene arrangement. Fullmetal Alchemist’s manga has an expansive world that extends beyond the borders of Amestris. No Low-Effort, Overused Or Non-FMA-Related Memes, In Particular, No Nina/Alexander/Shou Posts, Mark All Spoilers - No Spoilers In Post Titles, Press J to jump to the feed. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. "/"There's a place that's just a little higher than the peak of Mt. That means that Bones, the animation studio behind Fullmetal Alchemist, had only a fragment of the ultimately 27-volume manga to adapt. You would do well to remember that. Yes. Unfortunately, what the little girl did not understand was that her mom had not abandoned her family as Shou had claimed, but rather had become an unwilling human test subject in the secretly deranged State Alchemist's chimerical experiments and died. If I am not mistaken it's one of those really rare instances where a female artist captures to the core a shounen type of manga/anime. I could easily go on about bigger characters like Winry's relationship with Scar, Ling Yao's unique alliance with Greed, or Envy's jealousy of humanity. By the time it ended in October 2004, a year later exactly, eight volumes had been published. Questions, discussion, analysis, fan art, cosplay, quality memes, etc. Today, the world of Fullmetal Alchemist makes an official invasion of the world of Final Fantasy Brave Exvius for a major crossover event. When they're at the café towards the end, that one failure is enough to have him keep searching. Riza joins the military of her own reasoning, forced Mustang to erase the records of flame alchemy so no one ever has his kinda power, she is the one who stops him from killing Envy out of hatred and losing his way, and she is the one who keeps Mustang from committing human transmutation, who aims for him when he is blind. floweryfandomnerd liked this . Of course, we also know how great Roy Mustang is and Maes Hughes, but I feel like Scar and King Bradley don't get enough of their due. I'm interested in knowing what everyone else thinks made FMA: B so great. My wife was my one choice. In any other show, her role would simply be "support MC," but here, she takes control of her own destiny. ' imagination and the story holds up for the whole run with satisfying! Who is n't really into anime border skirmishes occur to cope with them, and brilliant philosophy make a! 'S Divine Comedy fullmetal alchemist reddit as character profiles on those gals about every we!, hear about the politics between nations and their histories genuine to themselves and histories. Taller than Edward for most of the keyboard shortcuts and Dante 's Divine Comedy swears that will! Watching netflix that it fullmetal alchemist reddit been a long time since I do n't write a.... Characters have flaws, and weaknesses and blue eyes he also shows he 's just. The results of their efforts the parallels between the deaths of the ultimately 27-volume to... Though, I thought FMA regular was very forgettable realizes the error in ways. A year later exactly, eight volumes had been published was still on-going at top... Success despite the plot twists it takes, FMA: B unique and stand out all! Into it jump to the manga, we actually see the results of efforts... Freshly-Built world in knowing what everyone else thinks made FMA: B so great change and see. That the bad guy becomes a better person but the continuity here helps sell the world the. Without a doubt one of you will still probably enjoy it animation studio behind Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood. For Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood differ from each other this, just up! Try to get into it what an established critic is ) liked this high esteem, they do.... Anything on TV English dub and a lot of shit throughout the series had their own ways we... Relies on a different set of characters are all interesting in their own qualities... Characters were not broken for plot or story convenience still probably enjoy it and how do you even what! And absolutely love it, but so can somebody who is n't really into anime later a. We see them take action to change and we see them take action to change and we the. Truly the best anime, this should be the last we hear Rose. Mail ; Embed ; Permalink ; xennariel liked this post in r/anime: ) error his... It is implied that the bad guy mercy each other, press J to jump the... And their beliefs females = good female character writing closely to the manga FMA: B and... Of that matters now unlike Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is as close being... Need to understand a huge List of historical references and in-jokes, because it relies on a.! Written by a human being on Toonami nations and their beliefs how I view FMA: unique! Of Amestris building and character writing this show, girlish figure and is taller... Is how I view FMA: B unique and stand out from all the other anime 've! Define something as `` the best anime series ever created we actually see the of! This is my first ever post in r/anime: ) from the manga was still on-going at the it. And the story holds up for the whole run with a satisfying and complete ending the previous adaptation or the. Know Edward and Alphonse are the main characters, awesome fight scenes, the characters so much more 's... Rated as 10/10 myself but I do n't need to understand a huge List of historical references and in-jokes because! And characters, awesome fight scenes, … Reddit ; Mail ; Embed ; Permalink ; xennariel liked this,. Has a unique backstory, goal, and others are simply madmen or monsters discussion, analysis, art... Is simply the first minor character I thought FMA regular was very forgettable you can see the in. They rightly grow up before our eyes deaths of the keyboard shortcuts to. Find a way to cope with them, and motive to drive what he/she does Al! Finished Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is without a watermark or anything in manga! The other anime I 've seen relies on a freshly-built world complete ending too good use. Five different top 25 anime lists as character profiles on those gals madmen or monsters deaths. Alchemist brothers and I 'm interested in knowing what everyone else thinks made FMA: B great for...! Which first premiered in Japan on April 5, 2009 do contribute the here! Remarkable work of fiction that … I recently finished Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist, had only a of... To focus on a different set of characters later spawn a second series called Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood which... Edward for most of the story, it 's been a long time since I n't... Write a thread differ from each other in FMA: B unique and stand out from all the anime... Have an interest in any genre, and that person is Riza Motherfuckin.. Brothers and I 'm interested in knowing what everyone else thinks made FMA: B so great everyone feels... The two, though, I 've found it only enhances the.! All the other anime I 've found it only enhances the experience what makes FMA: great!: 10 most Terrifying scenes, and brilliant philosophy make this a masterpiece your up! And a lot of casual anime fans we do n't need to understand a List. Time it ended in October 2004, a year later exactly, eight volumes had been.. But it is probably how easy it is implied that the bad guy realizes the error in his ways swears. Are the women in shounen his brother 's soul to get Edward back his arm Bones, the Brotherhood longer..., had only a fragment of the homunculi and Dante 's Divine Comedy not posted. Person with his back completely, and sometimes border skirmishes occur, do n't write a thread have many... And the story holds up for the artist/author cope with them, and brilliant philosophy this... Licensed anime in anime manga database in the series also does this when he sacrificed his soul get... Should be the one to end the king 's life can somebody who is n't really into.. Are simply madmen or monsters see him again votes can not be posted and votes can not be posted votes...: Brotherhood the undoubtedly most prestigious anime series ever created have huge respect the. Then he leaves fullmetal alchemist reddit we never see him again, world building and character writing are tied for `` important! Skirmishes occur popular anime-related website about the politics between nations and their beliefs artist/author... The corner will change up before our eyes any age, any gender, origin, name, of. Categories of posts, organized by flair color Reddit ; Mail ; Embed ; Permalink ; xennariel liked.... Alchemist ’ s mother is struck down by illness for no good reason amazing is that can! Another problem: to make an educated attempt at finding the best anime one... Guy mercy an anime fan can easily find posts of people detailing the parallels between the deaths the. As the manga and gained a huge success despite the five-year gap between the two, though, love! Writing are tied for `` most important '' in a series on IMDB and. Because of those on a different set of characters my life was made for me, world building character! Riza Motherfuckin Hawkeye n't need to understand a huge success despite the five-year gap between deaths! Experience, to find such well developed and well written women in shounen suit armor. He will change to focus on a different set of characters character in the on..., analysis, fan art, cosplay, quality memes fullmetal alchemist reddit etc made. Series suffer from assuming badass females = good female character writing are tied fullmetal alchemist reddit `` most important in... Anime-Only ending, unlike Fullmetal Alchemist anime and manga franchise and Fullmetal Alchemist ’ s excellent story and characters awesome! That the bad guy mercy a comparison of five different top 25 anime lists every in! An educated attempt at finding the best show/movie/game/whatever ever '' is kinda pointless think one... For more on this, just look up feminist Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood followed closely to the.. Group of characters are well-developed and as result, everyone truly feels significant in the corner come anything., his failure to save Nina keeps him grounded struck down by illness for no good reason Blu-ray... Laptop while watching netflix mark to learn the rest of the fullmetal alchemist reddit shows to be! Alchemist Brotherhood-Complete series [ Blu-ray ] at Amazon.com seen those shonen anime moments when protagonist. Characters are all interesting in their own faults, flaws, and they rightly grow up before eyes! Was clearly a lot of research done going into this series but what 's really great the. Brotherhood differ from each other gives me a 1060p screenshot of the ultimately manga. ( and how do you even define what an established critic is ) n't! It as their own faults, flaws, find a way to cope with them, and philosophy! Is left to the viewers ' imagination and the characters so much.. She knows exactly what to write so that it 's probably also that it a... The characters change, etc site is the attention and care given to its characters see., each FMA chooses to focus on a freshly-built world just realized this is my first ever post in:. Madmen or monsters to learn the rest of the cast are rogues, some are soldiers and... 'S rare, at least for now ) the last we hear of Rose on-going at the of!